Luckily Mr. Taubes has a more recent and more approachable book Why We Get Fat: And what to do about it.
Insulin and CarbsIf you read either book, you will learn about the mechanisms that insulin uses to move nutrients (fats and glucose (sugars)) into cells. You will also learn that the constant use of this process will eventually lead to insulin resistance in cells - namely muscle cells. Meaning that fat cells are much more likely to take in nutrients while muscle cells atrophy. This means your fat cells are getting bigger while your muscles starve.
I can not do all of the biochemistry justice in this simple review.
Not all fats are the enemy?For anyone raised in a western country, we have been indoctrinated for years that fat is a four-letter word. It will kill you and everyone you know. This book touches on why there is no good science to back that up. (For a deeper understanding of how nutritionist in the 50's used partial data sets and miss-correlated colesterol to heart desease to come up with this theory I recommend reading Good Calories, Bad Calories).
The book talks about how natural fats found in meat, avocados, butter, and cheeses not only don't cause heart disease in most people, they allow you to feel full so you can stop eating.
The book also added new biochemistry items I did not know about. Namely how Cortisol affects the body. The quote I highlighted is: "cortisol makes us store fat both directly (through LPL) and indirectly (through insulin). But then it works to release fat from our fat cells, primarily by stimulating HSL, just like other hormones."
I translated this to mean: Cortisol primes the pump such that if we have any nutrients that can be crammed into a fat cell (or noninsulin resistant cell), it will get crammed. However, if nothing is present Hormone Sensitive Lipase (HSL) will break down the stored triglycerides in fat cells to allow them to be released into the body. So if we are fasting during this process, and have only converted glucose in our system as our stress decreases, we will have mobilized a bunch of fat that our liver can turn into ketone bodies. Much of the body can run on ketone bodies rather than glucose. The liver can create glucose as needed for the other parts of the body that can only run on glucose.
But if you reach for that cookie, or beer, or other comfort food, LPL and insulin will not only prevent the freed fat from being used, but it will push more into your fat cells.
In the past six months since reading Good Calories, Bad Calories, by Gary Taubes I have lost over 40 pounds. The word "Hangry" can no longer be used to describe me. I have eaten more bacon, eggs, and steak than I ever thought was possible in the past. I also eat a lot more green leafy vegetables too (ten-year-old me would die).
I have made mistakes by eating too much protein, too many carbs, and not enough fat. There have been weeks where my diet has been dialed in, and I feel like a racehorse. And there have been weeks where I have just wanted to eat a
pint gallon of ice cream.
Luckily, thanks to the fact that I log my food into MFP (My Fitness Pal) (allowing a review of what has been eaten, what the nutrients were) combined with the biochemistry I have learned has allowed me to understand what could be happening and make corrections for it.